Deir Al-Kahf: Adaptation & Comparison Lab

العربية — المادة المقابلة

Start the experience now ↓

The idea: transfer the question before the structure

What happens when collection area, runoff coefficient or storage capacity changes? The Deir Al-Kahf lab compares two scenarios from a common framework, then lets you change one factor to examine its effect. It supports research thinking and comparison skills, without treating resemblance between sites as a success guarantee. It contains no measured climate values labelled as Umm Al-Jimal or Deir Al-Kahf; the places frame the research question.

What does the evidence support?

Ammon’s Northern Badia report mentions sites toward Deir Al-Kahf and visual exploration of water heritage. This supports a description of the field route, not a newly implemented system, soil samples or measured efficiency. We use the learning comparison to prepare questions for professional verification. We do not place Deir Al-Kahf in southern Jordan or assert geology, temperatures or costs without suitable records.

Source: DJAIRI team documents ancient water harvesting in the Northern Badia (Arabic report) — Ammon News · 2026-06-11 · Accessed: 8 October 2026.

Worked example: area and coefficient together

Fictional single-rain-event example: A = 500 m² × 20 mm × 0.6 = 6,000 litres of runoff. After 10% loss, 5,400 arrive and a 5,000-litre capacity retains 5,000. B = 800 m² × 20 mm × 0.3 = 4,800; after 10% loss, 4,320 arrive and are retained. Demand of 100 litres daily for 30 days is 3,000; storage exceeds demand by 2,000 in A and 1,320 in B. The larger area did not fully offset the lower coefficient.

Steps toward a fair test

Begin with equal inputs for both scenarios. Define one question, change one variable and record why. Label each value’s source: measurement, official record or learning assumption. Changing area, coefficient and capacity together compares packages but cannot attribute differences to one factor. This model reports storage differences and demand shortfalls; it does not simulate daily losses or seasonal sequences. Use the first notebook for day-by-day storage.

Activity: when does the ranking change?

Set B’s coefficient to 0.6 while keeping its capacity at 5,000: 8,640 arrive but only 5,000 are retained, matching A’s storage and increasing overflow. Before enlarging collection area, ask about capacity, maintenance, overflow routes and others’ rights. The useful output is a comparison record and verification questions, not a recommendation to build a channel or intervene in an archaeological site.

Two scenarios compared with the same equation

Try, adjust and retain the result

Begin with the example, then change inputs. Results are local educational calculations, not generative AI. This package does not save your inputs. Use fictional or general data only.

Local calculations, with no generative model or input storage. Bounds manage the exercise; they are not design standards.

Load an example or enter your values.